Pennsylvania Man Used Missing Woman's Facebook To Fool Family, Police Said

Authorities allege John Matthew Chapman confessed to killing Jaime Feden.

November 19, 2019

John Chapman (WPXI-TV screenshot)

John Chapman (WPXI-TV screenshot)

By: Aaron Rasmussen

Authorities in Pennsylvania allege a man has confessed to killing a woman and used her Facebook and cellphone to pretend to be her. Authorities suspect they've found the woman's remains but have yet to make a positive identification.

According to a copy of a criminal complaint obtained by Pittsburgh's WPXI-TV, John Matthew Chapman, 39, tricked Jaime Rae Feden, 33, into thinking they were driving to Las Vegas for vacation. But instead, around Sept. 25, Chapman allegedly lured Feden into the Nevada desert under the guise of a photoshoot, police said.

According to a confession Chapman has allegedly given to police, the photoshoot was a ruse. Instead of taking pictures, police claim Chapman told them he used cable ties to bind Feden to a sign and covered her nose and mouth with duct tape. After Feden suffocated to death, Chapman allegedly removed the bindings and her clothing. He then left her body behind before driving back to his home in Bethel Park, Pennsylvania, the complaint alleges.

Authorities further allege Chapman pretended to be Feden by using her Facebook messenger to contact her loved ones. Her close friend, Nikki Lawrence, told Buzzfeed News she suspects Chapman sent her text messages from Feden’s phone.

Feden's family grew suspicious and reported her missing on Nov. 14, nearly two months after they last saw her. Allegheny County detectives then contacted the Clark County Nevada Coroners Office and reportedly learned authorities there had discovered an unidentified body in early October. The body reportedly matches Felden’s description, but authorities said it could take weeks to positively identify the remains.

Lawrence told Buzzfeed News that Feden had VATER syndrome, a cluster of congenital disabilities that can affect the vertebrae, anus, trachea, esophagus, and kidneys. Lawrence said she believes Faden met Chapman around 2009, at a school for people with disabilities.

"She was such a sweetheart," Lawrence said. "She didn’t do anything wrong to anybody to deserve anything like this. She loved him, and she just wanted him to love her."

An aspiring medical assistant, Feden likely wasn’t aware her on-again, off-again boyfriend was married, Lawrence told Buzzfeed News.

Chapman’s wife of about a year, who reportedly believed her husband was driving to Vegas for a work trip, told WPXI-TV she learned of the case on Nov. 15, when he called her from the Bethel Park Police Department.

"He said he had murdered a woman," Maureen Chapman said.

Chapman reportedly claims she “was in disbelief" when he allegedly said, "I killed her because I had to.” She added, "Oh, my God, it's sick. It's really sick. I just want the truth as to what happened. I feel I'm owed that."

Kelly Murray, Matthew Chapman's ex-wife of seven years, told WPXI-TV he is a “manipulator” and a “liar.” She alleges he was romantically involved with Feden while they were married.

"He conned [Feden] into giving him every single penny she has," Murray alleged.

Murray said she too wants answers.

"Why? Why her," she asked. "Did she know something he didn't want anyone else knowing? … Has he done this before?"

The Bethel Park Police Department has charged Chapman with kidnapping, obstructing the administration of law, and criminal use of a communication facility.

Possible homicide charges are pending, but “first we have to locate Jamie — if she is, in fact, dead and if he is, in fact, telling the truth on this matter,” Police Chief Timothy O’Connor said, according to Pittsburgh's KDKA-TV.

Read more: WXPI, KDKA

Next Up

Where’s Chelsea Grimm? California Woman Vanishes While On Road Trip To Attend Wedding

“We are trying our best to hold onto positive outcome scenarios and put our faith in the authorities,” Stephen Grimm says about his missing daughter.

Mystery Surrounds Case Of California Woman Who Went Missing At A Yoga Retreat In Guatemala

Nancy Ng's family is desperately trying to find answers after the 29-year-old disappeared during a swim while kayaking on Lake Atitlán in Guatemala.

Colorado Police Searching For Woman Who Went Missing After Her First Night In Denver

After 32-year-old Indigenous woman Christine Tail moved to Denver with her girlfriend, she mysteriously went missing on June 14, 2023, within her first day in the city.

Ilene Rebecca Scott Disappeared The Day After Her Sixth Birthday In 1980

The 6-year-old California girl was last seen roller skating through her neighborhood on Dec. 20, 1980.

Tara Calico, Missing Since 1988, Might Have Been Spotted In A Mysterious Polaroid

Tara Calico's last words to her mother were, “Mom, if I'm not back by 12, come look for me."

12-Year-Old Celina Mays Was 9 Months Pregnant When She Vanished In 1996

Celina Mays was 12-years-old and two weeks away from giving birth when she disappeared in the middle of the night from her New Jersey home. If you have any information about Celina Mays, please call or text the IN PURSUIT hotline directly: 833-378-7783 (3-PURSUE).

Louisiana Woman Disappears While Road Tripping To Colorado To Start New Life

“Our family will never give up looking for our daughter,” the parents of Caitlyn Rose Case say.

5 Things That Still Bother Us About The Unsolved Maura Murray Case

On Feb. 9, 2004, UMass Amherst student Maura Murray left campus and crashed her car in Haverhill, New Hampshire. She has never been seen since.

Two Kidnapped Children Found Nearly One Year Later In Florida Supermarket

In February 2023, a routine vehicle tag check near a Winn-Dixie supermarket helped police locate the alleged kidnapper, 36-year-old Kristi Nicole Gilley, inside the store with the two children.

Store Clerk Deborah Deann Poe Disappeared During Overnight Shift At An Orlando Gas Station

An ambitious Florida woman vanished without a trace during her Feb. 4, 1990 shift at a convenience store. The case remains unsolved.